Bay Area Bottles vs Citadel Packaging: Packaging Supplier Comparison (2026)
65 shared products · data from PackVue index
Quick verdict
Bay Area Bottles and Citadel carry 65 of the same products on PackVue, though Bay Area Bottles has a noticeably larger catalog (413 vs 212 products indexed). On the 19 products where both suppliers publish pricing, Citadel comes in lower 11 times vs 7 for Bay Area Bottles. Contact both suppliers directly for shipping rates on your order size.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Bay Area Bottles | Citadel |
|---|---|---|
| Products on PackVue | 413 | 212 |
| Categories | BottlesCaps & ClosuresDispensing CapsJars | BottlesCaps & ClosuresDispensing CapsJars |
| Online pricing | Limited | Full |
| Shipping | No data | No data |
| Supplier site | bayareabottles.com | citadelpackaging.com |
Products Both Suppliers Carry (65)
Price comparison available for 5 of 10 shown.
| Product | Bay Area Bottles | Citadel | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2 oz Clear GLASS Boston Round [20-400] | $0.27 | $0.35 | Bay Area Bottles cheaper |
| 8 oz Natural HDPE Cylinder Round [24-410] | $0.33 | $0.28 | Citadel cheaper |
| 1 oz Amber GLASS Boston Round [20-400] | $0.25 | $0.22 | Citadel cheaper |
| 8 oz White HDPE Cylinder Round [24-410] | $0.38 | $0.32 | Citadel cheaper |
| 1 oz Clear GLASS Boston Round [20-400] | — | $0.23 | |
| 16 oz Amber GLASS Boston Round [28-400] | — | $2.05 | |
| 4 oz Natural HDPE Boston Round [24-410] | — | $0.34 | |
| 32 oz Natural HDPE Cylinder Round [28-410] | $1.05 | $0.52 | Citadel cheaper |
| Black PP Cap Closure [89-400] | — | $0.28 | |
| 4 oz Amber GLASS Boston Round [22-400] | — | $0.50 |
Showing 10 of 65 shared products. Browse all bottles or caps to compare prices across all suppliers.
Products Unique to Each Supplier
Who Should Choose Each Supplier?
Bay Area Bottles
Choose Bay Area Bottles if you need the widest product selection — Bay Area Bottles carries 413 products vs Citadel's 212.
Visit Bay Area BottlesCitadel
Choose Citadel if unit price is your top priority — Citadel comes in lower on 11 of 19 shared priced products.
Visit CitadelCan't decide? Skip both and save 20–40%.
Get a free China sourcing quote — no minimums, custom specs welcome.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is cheaper — Bay Area Bottles or Citadel?
Based on 19 shared products with published pricing, Citadel tends to offer lower unit prices (11 products cheaper vs 7 for Bay Area Bottles). Pricing varies by product and order quantity — always compare current prices on PackVue before placing an order.
Does Bay Area Bottles or Citadel have more packaging products?
Bay Area Bottles carries more products in PackVue's index (413 vs 212 canonical products). The two suppliers share 65 products in common. Note that PackVue's catalog is a snapshot — both suppliers may carry additional items not yet indexed.
Does Bay Area Bottles or Citadel offer free shipping?
Neither Bay Area Bottles nor Citadel advertises a universal free shipping threshold in their published policies. Both ship via major carriers (UPS, FedEx). Contact each supplier for a shipping quote based on your order size and ZIP code.
Browse products on PackVue